happy man in the outdoors

Ramelteon vs. Ambien (Zolpidem): A Comprehensive Comparison

Highlights 

  • Ramelteon and Ambien are effective solutions for insomnia, but they serve different purposes.
  • Ramelteon is best for initiating sleep, while Ambien helps with falling and staying asleep throughout the night.
  • Ambien tends to have more severe side effects than ramelteon, including a risk of dependency and next-day drowsiness.
  • Ambien is generally more cost-effective than ramelteon.
  • The best sleep aid for you will depend on your health history, current medications, and personal preferences.

Dr. Michael DiLeo
Latest posts by Dr. Michael DiLeo (see all)

In the world of sleep aids, ramelteon and Ambien stand out among their competitors. Let’s break down these two choices and see how they stack up.

What Is Ramelteon?

man in bed reaching for his phone

Ramelteon, often prescribed under the brand name Rozerem, is a melatonin receptor agonist approved to treat insomnia. 

Ramelteon Mechanism of Action

Ramelteon is a hypnotic medication that takes a unique approach to solving sleep-related issues. It’s classified as a melatonin receptor agonist, which means it targets the brain’s sleep-wake cycle. It mimics the action of melatonin, a hormone produced naturally by your body as part of your normal circadian rhythm.

Your body responds to darkness by releasing melatonin. This hormone tells your body that it’s time to wind down and sleep, which helps you to maintain a regular sleep pattern. By mimicking melatonin, Ramelteon accelerates the onset of sleepiness and makes it easier for you to fall asleep.

Common Uses for Ramelteon

Ramelteon is primarily used for treating insomnia, particularly in cases where falling asleep is the main issue. This is also referred to as sleep-onset insomnia. It’s approved for long-term use, and it can take a week or longer before you notice its effects. 

If you find yourself tossing and turning at night, unable to drift into the land of dreams, ramelteon may be the solution you’ve been searching for.

Side Effects of Ramelteon

Like any medication, ramelteon isn’t without its potential side effects. It’s important to be aware of these, though it’s worth noting that most individuals tolerate the drug well.

Common side effects include:

  • Dizziness
  • Drowsiness
  • Fatigue
  • Nausea 

Rare but serious side effects can include hormonal imbalance and allergic reactions. Tell your doctor right away if you experience serious side effects or concerning behaviors while taking ramelteon.

Precautions and Interactions for Ramelteon

It’s essential to avoid alcohol while taking ramelteon. Alcohol can increase the risk of side effects and worsen your sleeping problems.

Ramelteon can also interact with certain medications. It most commonly interacts with certain antifungal medications and antibiotics. It might also interact with medications used to treat anxiety, pain, or seizures. 

To see if a medication you’re already taking can potentially interact with ramelteon (Rozerem), visit the Drugs.com Drug Interaction Checker.

Take this medication exactly as prescribed and on an empty stomach to improve absorption. Do not take it unless you have time for at least seven hours of sleep.

What Is Ambien?

Ambien, also known as zolpidem, falls under the category of sedative-hypnotics. There are several generic options available on the market.

Ambien Mechanism of Action

Ambien works by slowing down brain activity to promote sleep. It influences certain chemicals in the brain that might be out of balance, particularly in individuals facing sleep issues or insomnia. This influence helps create the conditions for a restful night’s sleep. 

There are two primary forms of Ambien:

  • Immediate release. The immediate-release tablet helps you fall asleep when you first go to bed.
  • Extended release. The extended-release form has two layers. The first layer dissolves quickly, helping you fall asleep quickly. The second layer dissolves slowly, which helps you stay asleep throughout the night.

Common Uses for Ambien

Ambien has established its reputation as a short-term solution for insomnia. It offers relief for those struggling with both falling asleep and staying asleep.

Side Effects of Ambien

Ambien tends to have more severe side effects, including the risk of dependency and more pronounced next-day drowsiness. Though rare, Ambien may cause a severe allergic reaction. 

If you develop any signs of an allergic reaction, stop taking Ambien and seek emergency attention immediately.

Common side effects include: 

  • Daytime drowsiness 
  • Dizziness
  • Dry mouth
  • Feeling “drugged” or light-headed
  • Nasal or throat irritation
  • Nausea and other gastrointestinal issues
  • Weakness

One of the most concerning issues linked to Ambien is the risk of dependency. Prolonged or improper use of this medication can lead to withdrawal symptoms, including:

  • Nausea
  • Vomiting 
  • Stomach cramps
  • Sweating  
  • Tremors
  • Seizures in more severe cases 

It’s essential to follow your healthcare provider’s guidance and never abruptly stop taking Ambien.

Precautions and Interactions for Ambien

Avoiding alcohol or other sedatives is crucial when taking Ambien. Combining these substances can intensify their effects, potentially leading to severe drowsiness, accidents, or injuries.

Ambien can also interact with a variety of other medications, including prescription and over-the-counter (OTC) medications. It’s most likely to interact with medications like:

  • Antidepressants
  • Opioids
  • Muscle relaxants
  • Antihistamines
  • Anti-anxiety medications 
  • Anti-seizure drugs

Ambien’s interactions can make it less effective or, in some cases, more potent, and increase the risk of side effects.

For a full list of medications that can interact with Ambien, see the Drugs.com Drug Interaction Checker.

Special Precautions for Older Adults

Older adults should be cautious when considering Ambien, as they’re at a higher risk for experiencing serious side effects. This sleep medication can lead to memory issues and confusion (often called “Ambien amnesia”), especially in adults over 65. 

There’s also a possible connection between long-term Ambien use and a higher risk of developing Alzheimer’s disease in older adults. It’s important to note, however, that one study suggests the effects are reversible, and the connection has not been proven conclusively to date.

Ramelteon vs Ambien: A Comparative Analysis

Here’s a quick comparison of Ramelteon and Ambien:

RamelteonAmbien
Use- Helps with trouble falling asleep- Helps with trouble falling or staying asleep

Pros- Can be used long-term
- Not habit-forming
- Well-tolerated with fewer side effects
- Safe for older adults

- Works quickly
- Available as a lower-cost generic
- Comes in different strengths and forms
Cons- Needs to be taken on an empty stomach
- Often more expensive than Ambien
- May cause sleepwalking and other nighttime behaviors

- Should only be used for the short term
- May cause sleepwalking and other nighttime behaviors
- May cause withdrawal symptoms when stopped suddenly
- Controlled substance
- Causes more severe side effects in older adults

Effectiveness

Both ramelteon and Ambien are effective for treating insomnia, but they cater to slightly different needs. If you’re struggling with initiating sleep, ramelteon might be your go-to option. 

On the other hand, Ambien is often prescribed for individuals who face difficulties both falling asleep and staying asleep throughout the night. 

A study examined the effect of ramelteon on insomnia severity across different groups of people. After 12 weeks of treatment, there were significant improvements in insomnia severity, and participants reported better quality of life without safety concerns. 

Ramelteon was especially effective for older adults and participants who worked full-time, didn’t consume alcohol, and who took the drug more than one hour before bedtime. 

Side Effects

When it comes to side effects, ramelteon side effects tend to be less common and milder, making it an appealing choice for those concerned about potential drawbacks.

Ambien carries the risk of dependency and can leave you with a more pronounced sense of drowsiness the next day. 

While uncommon, some people who take sleep medications have reported activities like sleepwalking, talking, eating, or even driving while not fully awake. This can occur with both ramelteon and Ambien.

If you have a history of substance use disorder, suffer from depression, or are over the age of 65, you may want to think twice before considering Ambien as your primary solution. 

Research suggests that ramelteon is a safe and effective, non-habit-forming sleep aid for people with a history of substance use disorder and for older adults.

Drug Interactions

Both medications have the potential for interactions with other drugs, but Ambien casts a wider net. It can interact with various medications, including some OTC options. It can also interact with herbs, such as valerian, to increase its hypnotic effect, sometimes dangerously so.

Tell your doctor about any prescription or OTC medications or herbal supplements you’re taking, regardless of which sleep aid you choose. Your doctor may need to adjust your medication doses or monitor you closely to ensure your safety and the effectiveness of your treatment.

Cost

Of the two sleep aids, Ambien is often the more wallet-friendly option, making it accessible to a broader range of patients. Ramelteon, while effective, tends to be pricier than Ambien. 

Your insurance coverage will also impact your total out-of-pocket costs, so consider your coverage and budget when making your choice. 

Accessibility

Both drugs require a prescription. Unlike ramelteon, Ambien is potentially habit-forming and carries a controlled substance label. This means Ambien is subject to stricter regulations, which can create additional hoops to jump through for you to obtain or refill your prescription.

Patient Testimonials

The best option for you depends on your individual health history and personal preferences. Here’s what some users have to say about ramelteon and Ambien:

  • “I found ramelteon to be very effective for helping me fall asleep, but it didn’t do much for keeping me asleep.” – Sarah, 34
  • “Ambien worked like a charm for me, but I had to stop using it due to severe morning drowsiness.” – Mike, 45
  • “It (ramelteon) really works and I couldn’t be more pleased. No side effects and appreciate the best quality and quantity of sleep I’ve ever had.” – George, Age Unknown

Conclusion

man sleeping peacefully and soundly

Both ramelteon and Ambien have their merits and drawbacks. Ramelteon is a better option for those who have trouble falling asleep, and it isn’t habit-forming. Ambien is more versatile, but it carries a higher risk of side effects and dependency.

Always consult your healthcare provider for a treatment plan tailored to your needs, with considerations for:

  • Your symptoms. The specific symptoms and underlying causes of your sleep-related issues.
  • Your personal health factors. Your age and overall health, including any pre-existing medical conditions.
  • Potential interactions. The potential interactions with other medications you may be using, whether they are prescription, OTC, or herbal supplements.

Better Sleep and Better Health with eDrugstore

Don’t wait to get the help you need for a better night’s sleep. Poor sleep not only affects your quality of life, but it’s also linked to other health problems, like prostate cancer and erectile dysfunction.

At eDrugstore, we offer free consultations with licensed physicians to help you find the best solutions for insomnia and other health conditions, such as erectile dysfunction, sexual health, and weight loss. With eDrugstore, your order is shipped right to your front door, and shipping is always free.

Generic Viagra, Cialis or Propecia